THE BEST OF ALL TIME LISTS AND HOW IT WORKS
When the IRAs tackle a "best of" list such as the Best of the 1930s or the Best Westerns or whateveer, here is how it works.
1. Everyone submits an unranked list of favorite films from the decade/genre/whatever by email. Your list may contain up to 100 films, but no more. Submitting 87 films because you don't have time to discover more? That's fine! The more diverse movies mentioned the better. This list is not ranked. You may present them alphabetically or if you prefer indicate your favorites are at the top or however you choose.
2. Typically these personal picks are submitted around December 31.
2. Those movies are thrown into a big pile with each vote for each film garnering one point. This gives us an overall list of movies. Then we break ties and vote to eliminate the bottom few so we get a solid 100 films. This too is done by email.
3. Those movies are presented alphabetically to the group as the 100 movies on the final list.
4. Members then rank those 100 films from 100 points at the top for their favorite to 99 points for their second favorite down to 1 point for their least favorite. These too are submitted by email. Your ballots will be shared with everyone, so people can see what titles you're most excited about, the tabulations can be double checked by anyone else, etc.
5. This generates a final list of the 100, including ties and the like. The list is kept confidential until the in-person voting, though anyone may go to the bother of adding up all the ballots on their own, if they desire.
6. On the night devoted to the "best of" voting, we meet. The list is then voted on by batches of ten, starting with the movies ranked at 91-100. Members rank those movies to determine their order. Then we do the same with 81-90 until the grand finale when we rank the 1-10 films on the list.
Voila! A new list.
No comments:
Post a Comment